Since 2014, Mainstay has redeveloped over 120 single family homes, commercial sites, and urban-core commercial buildings.


Mainstay Property Group is a licensed real estate brokerage through the State of Indiana. Since 2014, Mainstay has brokered in excess of $5,000,000+ in both residential and commercial real estate acquisitions.


Mainstay and its principals actively manage several portfolio assets including redevelopment, ground-up construction, and raw land. The entire Mainstay Team is dedicated to the details of company assets, thus increasing net yield to investors.


Mainstay’s principals consult on behalf of several other local and regional developers, in order to attract optimal deal structures, joint-ventures, and capital placement for sponsor projects.

Mainstay Property Group is commercial real estate development firm located in Indianapolis, IN.  Focused on adding value to under-served neighborhoods, Mainstay originally began redevelopment efforts in residential neighborhoods, flipping over 150 homes since 2013. In recent years, Mainstay has a demonstrated a committed focus to commercial urban-infill development within the urban core of the Midwest. 

  • I invested a small portion of capital with Mainstay, in the fall of 2013. What the Mainstay team was able to do to the investment to not only multiply it, but also keep it protected and secured by quality real estate, has been impressive. I sleep easy at night knowing my retirement savings are invested with Mainstay.

    Dr. Drake Jennings
  • Mainstay has been a great company to work with. We confidently send our investors to Mainstay because we know they will take great care of our clients and identify appropriate investment opportunities. They are willing to work with our clients in a creative and “upfront” fashion, clearly explaining their options to ensure our investors are making well informed decisions. Very happy to do business with them.

    Grant Diggles
  • I invested $100,000 with Mainstay as part of a real estate development project in Indianapolis. I have been very impressed with Mainstay and their team. It is enjoyable to watch great returns, all while knowing you are adding real value to a neighborhood. Will continue to recommend!

    Arnold Spitz
  • My group and I have worked with Mainstay for several years. The company’s growth and professionalism continues to be unparalleled compared to any other real estate investment firm I have invested with. We are satisfied with the returns and enjoy working with them in many different investment sectors.”

    Sig Thorpe
  • My investment fund has placed several investments with Mainstay Property Group. We are planning on increasing our investment each year as we grow together. The Mainstay Team has been good to work with and we look forward to future investments together.

    Aniz Kanyaba-Onwa
Investment Opportunities

Mainstay understands that real estate is a numbers game, in a people business. Whether it be an investor, banking relationship, construction partner, or tenant, Mainstay serves the people of its community by providing solutions where others see problems. As an investor, Mainstay’s flexible deal structuring capabilities and capital markets relationships allow for an investment partnership that is unique the investor.